Trump’s SMS Scare Campaign Fail

Donald Trump seems to be everywhere. Personality and political capabilities apart, when it comes to marketing the guy is a showman. His presidential campaign gave him great visibility and he never misses an opportunity to promote himself. Well, almost never.

It was a surprise that he completely missed out the chance of using SMS as a key channel for his scare campaign. After Obama’s very effective SMS campaign in the previous elections, with millions of subscribers, exclusive news sent through SMS andAfter Obama’s very effective SMS campaign in the previous elections, with millions of subscribers, exclusive news sent through SMS a successful approach to raise donations, I expected Trump to nail it at this elections. Instead, he used the channel in a very not-Trump-like monotonous way.

Taking a look at his Twitter, it’s easy to see what his message is all about:

sms  campaign

After Obama’s very effective SMS campaign in the previous elections, with millions of subscribers, exclusive news sent through SMS andAfter Obama’s very effective SMS campaign in the previous elections, with millions of subscribers, exclusive news sent through SMS a successful approach to raise donations, I expected Trump to nail it at this elections.

After Obama’s very effective SMS campaign in the previous elections, with millions of subscribers, exclusive news sent through SMS andAfter Obama’s very effective SMS campaign in the previous elections, with millions of subscribers, exclusive news sent through SMS a successful approach to raise donations, I expected Trump to nail it at this elections.

SMS campaign

After Obama’s very effective SMS campaign in the previous elections, with millions of subscribers, exclusive news sent through SMS andAfter Obama’s very effective SMS campaign in the previous elections, with millions of subscribers, exclusive news sent through SMS a successful approach to raise donations, I expected Trump to nail it at this elections.

Considering that promoting fear is his main strategy, imagine what he could have achieved with proper use of this channel. SMS is short, direct and has a 98% open rate. What a better way to “nurture” fear than sending short effective messages over a long period of time?

So let’s see where he failed and what he could have done differently.

Trump’s SMS Campaign

In every rally, news conference and public speaking appearance of Donald Trump, you can see a printed banner that includes the phrase Text “Trump” to 88022, promising exclusive updates. By texting “Trump”, the following happens:

SMS campaign

After Obama’s very effective SMS campaign in the previous elections, with millions of subscribers, exclusive news sent through SMS andAfter Obama’s very effective SMS campaign in the previous elections, with millions of subscribers, exclusive news sent through SMS a successful approach to raise donations, I expected Trump to nail it at this elections.

After that first interaction, very little content is shared through SMS. The only messages received during the research for this article were announcing the primaries for that particular state:

SMS campaign

After Obama’s very effective SMS campaign in the previous elections, with millions of subscribers, exclusive news sent through SMS andAfter Obama’s very effective SMS campaign in the previous elections, with millions of subscribers, exclusive news sent through SMS a successful approach to raise donations, I expected Trump to nail it at this elections.

From a marketing perspective, we can point out some of the main flaws in Trump’s SMS campaign:

Unclear benefit

It’s unclear what kind of recurring messages from Donald Trump you’ll receive when subscribing. “Exclusive updates” doesn’t say much and users may be frustrated when expecting a consistent amount of text messages, especially getting closer to elections, but receive close to nothing.

In contrast, Obama’s campaign collected permissions and explicitly told them what they are opting into. He also offered incentives for the ones who subscribed, such as special bumper stickers, ringtones and wallpapers.

Non-compliant

Mobile phones and text messages are highly personal, therefore, commercial text messages shouldn’t be just like any other advertisements. You need to build trust with your audience.

Trump’s campaign sent unsolicited SMS messages to Chicago voters, violating the Telephone Consumer Protection Act, which explicitly states that the recipient must opt-in for every campaign. As a result, he was sued in a class action complaint.

Uninteresting content

Trump underestimated SMS as a marketing channel and didn’t develop a proper strategy for it. The results were generic messages and replicated content from emails.

Lack of interactivity

Establishing a “2-way” conversation builds rapport with your audience and it’s a powerful tool to obtain insights.

Obama’s campaign contained a continuing dialogue. The campaign used text messages to direct voters to more in-depth information or by giving them choices by using keywords such as “SAVE”, “LEARN”, “GIVE”, “YES”, “NO”, etc. It also allows subscribers to either tone down or dial up text message frequency.

This allows people who doesn’t like receiving lots of messages to “tone down” message frequency instead of completely unsubscribing. On the other hand, those who want more information could opt-in for increased message frequency.

How Trump’s campaign could have been better

One thing Trump did correctly was to send alerts and reminders on the election day. However, with a few tweaks in his messages, he could have been much more effective. For example:

Election Day Alerts

SMS campaign

After Obama’s very effective SMS campaign in the previous elections, with millions of subscribers, exclusive news sent through SMS andAfter Obama’s very effective SMS campaign in the previous elections, with millions of subscribers, exclusive news sent through SMS a successful approach to raise donations, I expected Trump to nail it at this elections.

 

The CTA “Forward this SMS to your family and friends” can help reach other voters who might support Trump as well.

 

 

 

SMS campaign

After Obama’s very effective SMS campaign in the previous elections, with millions of subscribers, exclusive news sent through SMS andAfter Obama’s very effective SMS campaign in the previous elections, with millions of subscribers, exclusive news sent through SMS a successful approach to raise donations, I expected Trump to nail it at this elections.

Having multiple CTAs is also an effective way to keep your audience engaged. Don’t miss our the opportunity to push your audience to social media and spread the message.

Remember, most phones are smart phones so you can easily link to social and web pages.

 

 

 

 

 

Before Election Day 

Here’s another example of a campaign Trump could have been better:

SMS campaign

After Obama’s very effective SMS campaign in the previous elections, with millions of subscribers, exclusive news sent through SMS andAfter Obama’s very effective SMS campaign in the previous elections, with millions of subscribers, exclusive news sent through SMS a successful approach to raise donations, I expected Trump to nail it at this elections.

Why is this effective?

 

Personalized

This personalized SMS uses the name of the individual and adapts the sender to his electoral division. It also informs the right contact from the party to be contacted, providing a feeling of trust and connection between the sender and the recipient.

SMS campaign

After Obama’s very effective SMS campaign in the previous elections, with millions of subscribers, exclusive news sent through SMS andAfter Obama’s very effective SMS campaign in the previous elections, with millions of subscribers, exclusive news sent through SMS a successful approach to raise donations, I expected Trump to nail it at this elections.

 

Interactive

In our example, the SMS allows the recipient to specify his area of concern and request more information by replying “SAVE”, promoting a 2-way conversation based on his interests.

SMS campaign

After Obama’s very effective SMS campaign in the previous elections, with millions of subscribers, exclusive news sent through SMS andAfter Obama’s very effective SMS campaign in the previous elections, with millions of subscribers, exclusive news sent through SMS a successful approach to raise donations, I expected Trump to nail it at this elections.

Measurable

The URL provided in the message tracks the clicks to it and also the number of replies. Being able to track how many people responded to your messages allows you to measure the impact of your campaign and more importantly identify engaged recipients for follow-up later.

SMS campaign

After Obama’s very effective SMS campaign in the previous elections, with millions of subscribers, exclusive news sent through SMS andAfter Obama’s very effective SMS campaign in the previous elections, with millions of subscribers, exclusive news sent through SMS a successful approach to raise donations, I expected Trump to nail it at this elections.

Clear and Multiple CTAs

The SMS example had a clear call-to-action (CTA) to raise awareness.

Multi-channel

Multiply the impact by pushing interested recipients to other channels, such as social media.

SMS campaign

After Obama’s very effective SMS campaign in the previous elections, with millions of subscribers, exclusive news sent through SMS andAfter Obama’s very effective SMS campaign in the previous elections, with millions of subscribers, exclusive news sent through SMS a successful approach to raise donations, I expected Trump to nail it at this elections.

Parting Thoughts

SMS is a very effective channel to achieve personal engagement with voters and to communicate time-sensitive information. It provides a different approach amidst the super-saturated marketing channels in election time.

However, SMS needs to be contemplated as a unique channel with its particularities, and simply replicating content from other channels is not effective.

An SMS campaign can only be successful when being compliant, having a clear strategy and being relevant to your audience.

*Disclaimer: I have no affiliation with any political parties.

Suggested Posts

Job Opportunity: Junior Marketing Manager

Experienced in Marketing or a Masters student? Want hands-on experience working in a fun, dynamic and fast-growing Australian company? Get full ramp up training, excellent working conditions and loads of learning, working with some of the best brands in Australia. Convenient CBD location and flexible working conditions.

Job Opportunity: Digital Marketing Coordinator

Masters Student? Want hands-on experience working in a fun, dynamic and fast-growing Australian company? Get full ramp up training, excellent working conditions and loads of learning, working with some of the best brands in Australia. Convenient CBD location and flexible working conditions.

Marketo and LinkedIn are now driving Accounts Based Experiences (ABX)

Very recently, Adobe announced the extension of its partnership with Microsoft and its new integration with LinkedIn. This new integration is geared toward improving Accounts Based Experiences (ABX). This partnership will enable the delivery of targeted content for a more personalized experience on B2B platforms like LinkedIn.

A/B Testing 101 in Marketo

Why is AB Testing in Marketo important? As Marketo likes to say, “we’re marketers, not mind readers.”Emails and landing pages are key marketing components for any successful marketer to master. But how are we supposed to know which ones engage people the most? Nowadays, it’s also getting more and more difficult to grab and retain the attention of audiences. It’s vital, now more than ever, to be able to determine which versions of our marketing materials generate the best results. And A/B testing is a simple, inexpensive way to do just that.

Marketo and LinkedIn are now driving Accounts Based Experiences (ABX)

Very recently, Adobe announced the extension of its partnership with Microsoft and its new integration with LinkedIn. This new integration is geared toward improving Accounts Based Experiences (ABX). This partnership will enable the delivery of targeted content for a more personalized experience on B2B platforms like LinkedIn.

A/B Testing 101 in Marketo

Why is AB Testing in Marketo important? As Marketo likes to say, “we’re marketers, not mind readers.”Emails and landing pages are key marketing components for any successful marketer to master. But how are we supposed to know which ones engage people the most? Nowadays, it’s also getting more and more difficult to grab and retain the attention of audiences. It’s vital, now more than ever, to be able to determine which versions of our marketing materials generate the best results. And A/B testing is a simple, inexpensive way to do just that.

How to Build Complex Engagement Programs in Marketo

Lead nurturing is an effective method of engaging leads in any part of your customer lifecycle. Leads receive content designed to resonate with them, depending on where they’re at in the buying cycle. This means that you can develop a relationship with your leads over a period of time. So where do you start when building an engagement program in Marketo?

Brilliant stuff you can do with Drift and Marketo in your company

You have probably felt the big buzz around Conversational Marketing; it's on every other website, showing up as a pop-up box that asks you if they can be of help. It's such a trendy topic that the search query "Chatbot" has over 35k monthly searches in the US. Now, you may be asking yourself, why are so many people interested? Well, the answer is short and powerful: Because it works; and it works even better when connected to Marketo.

University of the People (UoPeople) Increased Engagement and Conversion to 72% with Hoosh’s 2-Way SMS Solution

Established in 2009, University of the People (UoPeople) is the world’s first tuition-free, non-profit, American accredited distance learning university. With a ground-breaking online learning model and academic leadership stemming from Oxford, Harvard, and Columbia University, UoPeople is the most accessible and affordable distance learning university that offers high-quality educational opportunities to anyone in the world who has completed high school in their native country.

AUSTRALIAN CATHOLIC SUPERANNUATION ACHIEVED A RESPONSE RATE OF 56% WITH HOOSH’S SMS PROGRAM

An industry super fund for all Australians, Australian Catholic Superannuation aims to maximize retirement benefits by providing all individuals with various venture alternatives that permits lifetime of investment. All catholic sectors related to education, healthcare, aged care and welfare are catered by Australian Catholic Superannuation. As a matter of fact, it has earned a variety of industry awards in the recent years. Australian Catholic Superannuation was the winner of the Innovation and Transformation award at the Conexus Financial Superannuation Awards 2017. Recognised as an ABA100 winner for process improvement in 2017. Received the Australian Institute of Superannuation Trustees 2016 Best Member Facing Project (FUM under $10bn) Award for Excellence and many more recognitions beside these awards mentioned.

How Universities Can Increase Engagement through SMS

Text messages are usually considered the main distraction in the school environment, but they can also be an opportunity for University to engage with their students. See the possibilities.

Skip to toolbar